What subrogation is
Subrogation is your carrier's right, after it pays a covered loss, to step into the insured's shoes and pursue the party responsible for the loss.
Whether that right exists, and how far it goes, depends on the policy, the facts, the contracts involved and the law of the state. What doesn't change is that the right can be lost early, often before anyone realizes there was one. That's where you come in.
Rules differ by state
Before anyone counts on a recovery, the file needs to be checked against the rules that apply. Some of the most common limits:
- Payment usually comes first. In most cases, the carrier's right to pursue arises once it has paid.
- No recovery against your own insured. Carriers generally can't subrogate against their own insured, and some states extend that to people treated as co-insureds, like tenants in certain landlord and tenant losses.
- Waivers in contracts. Leases, construction contracts and other agreements often include a waiver of subrogation that can bar the claim.
- Made whole and similar rules. Some states require the insured to be fully compensated before the carrier recovers anything.
- Coverage and claim limits. Some states restrict subrogation for certain coverages or certain kinds of claims.
- Deadlines and notice rules. Statutes of limitation, statutes of repose and short notice periods for claims against government bodies can end a claim early.
Your carrier's subrogation team and counsel decide how these apply. Your job is to keep every option open until they do.
Why it starts with you
- Evidence disappears fast. Failed parts get thrown out, scenes get cleaned up, and cameras record over themselves.
- Rights can be waived without anyone noticing. A signed release, a lease clause or a quick settlement can end a recovery before it starts.
- Recovery isn't only SIU's job. SIU looks for fraud. Whether the right to recover survives depends on what happens on your desk at the start.
Signs someone else may be responsible
Flag the file for your subrogation team if any of these come up:
- A product or appliance failed, like a water heater, supply line, dishwasher, dryer, battery or space heater.
- Someone recently worked on it: a plumber, electrician, roofer, HVAC company or contractor.
- It came from somewhere else: a neighbor, the unit above, a tenant, a guest or a business next door.
- A driver, a vehicle or a work truck was involved.
- A utility or city system was involved, like a power surge, gas leak, water main or sewer backup.
- The property was in someone else's care, like a repair shop, mover, valet or storage company.
- A fire spread from somewhere else.
How to protect the right to recover
- Spot it early. Ask what happened and what failed, and write down the insured's own words, including the brand and model of anything that failed.
- Keep the evidence. Ask the insured, and any contractor or cleanup crew, not to repair, replace or throw away anything that may have caused the loss.
- Hold the scene. Ask that nothing be touched, moved or repaired until it's been documented, except what's needed to keep the damage from getting worse.
- Decide about an expert early. Ask whether an origin and cause investigator should look at the scene, get approval for the cost, and note the decision in the file either way.
- Photograph what matters. Wide shots of the scene, close-ups of where it started, and every label with a model or serial number.
- Look for waivers and releases. Ask whether the insured signed anything with the other side, and get copies of any lease, contract or work order involved.
- Get names and records. Who installed it, who repaired it, who lives next door or upstairs, and any insurance information they've shared.
- Note the deadlines. Write down the date of loss, and flag any claim that may involve a city, county or public utility, since their notice periods can be short.
- Refer it early. Send the file to your subrogation team as soon as you see a sign, before the claim is paid and closed.
What to avoid
- Don't let evidence be tested, taken apart or discarded without notice to everyone involved. That can lead to a spoliation of evidence claim.
- Don't tell the insured what to do about a release. Explain the risk instead. Signing a release or settling directly with the other side can cause an overpayment on the claim, keep supplemental damages from being paid, and end your carrier's right to recover. Ask them to talk with you before they sign anything.
- Don't agree to anything with the responsible party that could limit your carrier's rights, without your subrogation team's OK.
- Don't promise the insured a recovery. Tell them their carrier will look into it.
Letters and guides that help
- Referral to Subrogation: send the file to your recovery team in a few minutes
- Subrogation Opening Letter to Insured: what to expect, and what to keep
- Evidence Preservation and Joint Scene Exam Notice: ask the other side to keep the evidence
- Expert Retention Letter: assign an origin and cause investigator
- State Rules: fault rules and filing deadlines, state by state
- Loss Guides: step-by-step guides for 44 kinds of losses