A car in your living room or a crushed garage door is a shock. But here's the good news: when a driver hits your property, their auto insurance is usually the one that pays. Most auto policies include property damage liability, the coverage for damage their vehicle does to other people's property. You don't have to start with your own insurance.
Is anyone hurt, or is the house unsafe? Call 911 first. If a wall, beam or porch was hit, stay out of that part of the house until a contractor or the fire department says it's safe.
Step 1: In the first hour
- Don't let them leave. Get the driver's name, address, phone number and driver's license number. Snap a photo of their insurance card and license plate.
- Ask who owns the vehicle. If it's a parent's car, a work truck or a rental, get the owner's name and insurance too.
- Call the police, even if the driver is calm and apologetic. Ask for the report number before the officer leaves.
- Hit record. Take a slow video of the vehicle right where it stopped, the tire marks in your yard, and every bit of damage. Say the date and time out loud.
- Check the cameras. Your doorbell camera, a neighbor's camera, or a business across the street may have caught it. Download the clip today, before it records over.
- Get witnesses. A name and phone number from anyone who saw it happen.
Step 2: Keep the damage from getting worse
You're expected to protect your property from more damage, and those costs count.
- Board up openings and cover holes so rain and animals stay out.
- Shut off utilities to the damaged area if gas, water or power lines were hit, and call the utility company.
- Keep every receipt: plywood, tarps, a board-up service, a hotel night if you couldn't stay home.
- Don't do permanent repairs yet. Get a written estimate first, so their adjuster can see what was damaged.
Step 3: Who to call
- The driver's auto insurance carrier. The claims number is on their insurance card. Say: "I'd like to open a third-party property damage claim against your insured." Give them the date, your address, their insured's name, and the police report number.
- Write down the claim number and your adjuster's name. You'll need both for everything that follows.
- Your own insurance carrier (optional). Some policies ask you to report any damage, so check yours. Telling your carrier what happened isn't the same as filing a claim.
Step 4: What to ask for
- Repairs to your house, garage, fence, porch, mailbox or landscaping, by a contractor you choose
- Emergency costs like board-up, tarps and debris removal
- Damaged belongings inside, like a car in the garage, tools, or furniture
- Hotel or temporary housing if your home wasn't safe to live in
- An engineer's inspection if a wall or foundation was hit
Step 5: Send the letter
Put everything in writing with our Letter to a Driver Who Hit Your Home or Garage. Send one copy to the driver and one to the vehicle's owner, if they're different people, and ask them to forward it to their insurance carrier.
What to attach: your photos and video stills, the police report number, the repair estimate, and your receipts.
Step 6: Follow up
- Call your adjuster every week until you hear back. Write down the date, who you spoke with, and what they said.
- Low offer? Send a second estimate and explain what their number leaves out.
- They won't respond? You can file a complaint with your state's Department of Insurance. It's free.
- Driver had no insurance? You can ask the driver to pay directly, go to small claims court, or use your own homeowner's coverage. Your carrier can then go after the driver.
- Don't wait. Every state has a deadline for property damage claims. Start right away.
Quick checklist
This guide is general information to help you handle your own claim. It isn’t legal advice. Rules differ by state, so check yours, and talk to an attorney if someone was hurt or a lot of money is at stake.