A limb crashing onto your roof in the middle of a storm is scary. Before you call anyone, know this: whether your neighbor's insurance pays usually comes down to one question. Was the tree healthy, or did your neighbor have reason to know it was a danger?
A healthy tree that falls in a big storm is often treated as nobody's fault, and each side covers their own property. But a dead, rotting or leaning tree, or one your neighbor was warned about, is a different story. That's when their insurance may be responsible.
Is anyone hurt, or is a limb on a power line? Call 911 or the utility company first. Stay away from downed lines.
Step 1: Stay safe, then document
- Stay off the roof. Film from the ground, a ladder at the gutter line, or a window. Your safety matters more than any photo.
- Hit record. Walk around your house slowly and film the limb, the roof, the gutters and every room with a leak. Say the date and time out loud.
- Film the tree it came from. This is the most important video you'll take. Get the break, the stump, and the whole tree.
- Look for signs the tree was a danger: dead branches with no leaves, mushrooms or fungus at the base, hollow spots, cracks, a heavy lean, or bark falling off.
- Write down any warnings. Did you ever tell your neighbor the tree looked dead? Did the city or an arborist? Dates, texts and letters all matter.
Step 2: Stop more damage
You're expected to keep the damage from getting worse, and those costs count.
- Get a tarp on the roof as soon as it's safe. A roofer or tree service can do it.
- Catch leaks inside with buckets and towels, and move belongings out of the way.
- Keep every receipt: the tarp, the tree removal, a hotel night if you had to leave.
- Ask to keep the wood. Ask the tree service to leave the broken limb and a piece of the trunk if they can. An arborist may need to see the rot.
Step 3: Tell your neighbor, in writing
Use our Neighbor's Tree Notice Letter. It tells your neighbor what happened, asks them to forward it to their homeowner's insurance carrier, and asks them to keep the stump and trunk until someone can look at them.
Stick to the facts in the letter. Save the conversation about whose fault it was for a phone call with their adjuster.
Step 4: Work with their insurance adjuster
When their adjuster calls, ask, show and negotiate:
- Ask them to cover your roof repair, interior damage, tree removal from your property and emergency costs.
- Show them your videos of the tree, the signs it was dead or leaning, and any warnings your neighbor received.
- Negotiate. If they say it was an "act of God," point back to the evidence that the tree was a danger. Consider a written opinion from a certified arborist.
If they say no
- Your own homeowner's policy usually covers a tree falling on your house. You'd pay your deductible, and your insurance carrier can then go after the neighbor's carrier. That's called subrogation, and it's how you can get your deductible back.
- Small claims court is an option for smaller amounts.
- Don't wait. Every state has a deadline for property damage claims.
Before it happens next time
See a tree next door that looks dead? Our Dangerous Tree Warning Letter puts your neighbor on notice before it falls. That letter can make all the difference later.
Quick checklist
This guide is general information to help you handle your own claim. It isn’t legal advice. Rules differ by state, so check yours, and talk to an attorney if someone was hurt or a lot of money is at stake.