If another driver hit you and it was their fault, you don't have to use your own insurance. You can file a claim directly with the other driver's insurance carrier. It's called a third-party claim, and when it's done right, you don't pay a deductible.
Here's exactly how to do it.
Were you hurt? This guide is about your car and your property. If you or a passenger were injured, get checked by a doctor and talk to a personal injury attorney before you sign anything or give a statement about your injuries.
Step 1: At the scene, get these things
- The other driver's name, phone number, and address
- Their insurance carrier and policy number. Take a photo of their insurance card.
- Their license plate and the make, model, and color of their car
- The police report number and which department responded. Always call the police, even for a small accident.
- Witness names and phone numbers
- Photos: both cars, the damage up close, where the cars ended up, skid marks, traffic signs, and the other driver's plate
Step 2: Who to call
- The police non-emergency line, a few days later, to get a copy of the police report.
- The other driver's insurance carrier. The claims phone number is on their insurance card or the carrier's website. Tell them:
- "I'd like to open a third-party property damage claim against your insured."
- Give them the date, place, their insured's name, and the police report number.
- Write down the claim number and your adjuster's name. You'll need both for everything that follows.
- Your own insurance carrier (optional). You can let them know about the accident without filing a claim. Some policies require you to report it, so check yours. You only file with your own carrier if the other side refuses to pay.
About recorded statements: the other carrier may ask to record a statement. Stick to the facts: where you were, what you saw, what happened. Don't guess, and don't talk about injuries.
Step 3: What to ask for
You can ask the other driver's insurance carrier to pay for:
- Repairs at a shop you choose. You don't have to use their shop.
- A rental car while yours is being fixed, or loss of use if you don't rent one
- Towing and storage
- Personal property that was damaged in the car, like a phone, car seat, or laptop
- Diminished value, meaning your car is worth less after an accident. Many states allow this claim, so ask.
- If the car is totaled: its fair market value right before the accident, plus the taxes and fees to replace it in many states
Keep every receipt. If you don't have a receipt for something, it's hard to get paid for it.
Step 4: Send the letter
After your call, put everything in writing with our Car Accident Claim Letter to the Other Driver's Insurance. It lists your costs, points to the police report, and asks them to confirm the claim.
Where to send it:
- By email to your adjuster, if they gave you an email address. That's the fastest.
- By certified mail to the claims address on the carrier's letters or website, with your claim number on it.
- Always include the claim number on the letter and on every page you attach.
What to attach: the police report, photos, the repair estimate, and your receipts.
Step 5: Follow up
- Call every week if you don't hear back. Write down the date, who you spoke with, and what they said.
- Ask for their decision on liability. They'll accept it fully, partly, or deny it.
- If they accept part of it, they may only pay a percentage. You can ask what facts they relied on and send any proof that shows otherwise.
- If they stall or deny it, you can:
- Use your own collision coverage. You pay your deductible, and your insurance carrier goes after the other carrier to recover it for you. That process is called subrogation, and it's how you can get your deductible back.
- File a complaint with your state's Department of Insurance if the carrier won't respond. Every state has one, and it's free.
- File in small claims court against the other driver for smaller amounts.
- Don't wait too long. Every state has a deadline for property damage claims, often two years or more. Start right away.
What if the other driver has no insurance?
Check your own policy for uninsured motorist property damage or collision coverage. Your insurance carrier can pay, then try to recover from the other driver directly.
Quick checklist
This guide is general information to help you handle your own claim. It isn’t legal advice. Rules differ by state, so check yours, and talk to an attorney if someone was hurt or a lot of money is at stake.