← Demand letters

Response to a Low Offer from the Adverse Carrier

Send toThe adjuster who made the offer
WhenTheir offer is well under the demand and they haven't said which item they dispute

Tips for this letter

Show tips

A first offer is usually a percentage of the demand with no explanation. This letter puts the burden back where it belongs: the demand is made of payments actually issued, each with proof, so the carrier has to say which item it disputes and why, or revise the offer.

  • Ask for the basis. Which payment is unreasonable, unrelated, or reduced for comparative fault, and what evaluation is behind their number.
  • Restate the proof. Paid invoices, estimates and the report that establishes liability are already in their file. Point to them.
  • Keep the door open. A reasoned explanation gets a fair look; a bare percentage doesn't.
  • Say what comes next if it isn't resolved: arbitration or suit for the full amount.
  • Get authority first before you accept anything under the demand. In Subrobuddy, a settlement under your company's line goes to a supervisor.

The letter

Fill in the boxes and the letter updates as you type. Anything you leave blank stays [in brackets]. What you type stays on your device unless you tap Save to My Letters. Then download it as Word or PDF, print it, email it, or save it to the claim.

[Adverse Carrier Name]
Attn: [Adjuster Name]
[Street Address]
[City, State ZIP]

[Today's Date]

RE: Response to Your Offer

Your Claim No.: [Adverse Claim Number]
Our Insured: [Insured's Name]
Our Claim No.: [Client Claim Number]
Your Insured: [Responsible Party]
Date of Loss: [Date of Loss]
Our Demand: $[Total Demand]
Your Offer: $[Offer Amount], dated [Offer Date] ([Offer Percent]% of the demand)

Dear [Adjuster Name]:

Thank you for your offer of $[Offer Amount] on [Offer Date]. We are not able to accept it.

[Client Name]'s demand of $[Total Demand] is made up of payments actually issued for this loss, plus the insured's $[Insured's Deductible] deductible, and every item is supported by the invoices, estimates and proof of payment already in your file:

Your offer is $[Offer Gap] below the demand and does not identify which item is in dispute. If your office contends that a payment was unreasonable, unrelated to the loss, or should be reduced for comparative fault, please tell us which one and why, and send the estimate or evaluation behind your figure, so we are comparing the same things. Liability is established by [the enclosed police, fire, or expert report], and the amounts paid reflect the actual cost of the repairs and replacements.

We will give a reasoned explanation a fair review. Absent one, we ask that your office revise the offer to the full demand of $[Total Demand] by [Reply By Date]. If this cannot be resolved, [Client Name] may pursue arbitration or suit to recover the full amount, with interest and costs where the law allows.

Payment instructions

Make payment payable to [Your Company Name] as agent for [Client Name], and include our claim number, [Client Claim Number], on the check.

Mail to: [Your Company Address]

Sincerely,

[Name]
[Title]
[Company]
[Address]
[Phone] · [Email]