A thousand paths to recovery. One formula.
Working for a TPA or an insurance carrier doesn’t mean anyone trained you well. SubroCareer helps you spot recovery avenues you’ve never been shown, and always know your next step.
Water heater failure, installed by a big-box store’s subcontractor
Step 3 of 6 · Investigate
Enough is enough
You’re likely handling more than 250 claims at once. And you’re expected to know them all.
- Fire
- Water
- Weather
- Automobile
- Medical
- Marine vessel
- Jewelry
- Install error
- Flooring defects
- Plane accident
- Theft
- Vandalism
- Cargo
- Explosion
- Gas leak
- Power surge
- Utility failure
If a product, person, pet or possession can be covered and reimbursed by insurance, it can be subrogated.
That’s over a thousand paths to a recovery, and a huge weight on any one specialist. Each investigation is different. The formula is the same.
See the formula →Built to help you grow
This isn’t about taking work from TPAs or insurance carriers. It’s about helping you, the specialist doing the work, get better one file at a time.
Learn new avenues of recovery
Find the responsible parties and recovery paths you were never taught to look for.
Know the next step
Every guide follows the same six steps, so you always know where a file stands and what comes next.
Work smarter, not harder
Ready letters, checklists and contacts mean less time starting from scratch on every claim.
Everything you need, in one place
No one hands you a manual for this job. This is the one we wish we'd had.
Letter Library
A letter for every stage of a file, from the first notice to the final closing. Fill in the blanks and send.
Open the library →Cause-of-Loss Guides
What happened, who might be responsible, and what proof to gather. One friendly guide per type of loss.
Pick a topic →Checklists
Step-by-step checks, like reviewing a release before you sign it, so nothing slips through.
See the checklists →Create your free account
Set up your details once. Subrobuddy remembers the rest.
Create my free account →Every tool free for 7 days, then $10 a month. No card needed to start. See pricing
- Your signature, filled inYour name, title and company appear on every letter.
- Save letters for laterStart a letter today, pick up right where you left off tomorrow.
- Keep your contacts handySave the carriers and companies you write to, then use them on any letter.
- Private to youOnly you can see what you save.
What is subrogation?
An insurance carrier pays for a loss. If another party is responsible for the cause, the insurance carrier asks that party to pay it back.
That's subrogation. And the six steps below are how it gets done.
Why it's fair
- The responsible party pays. The loss happened because of something another party is responsible for. So that party should pay, not the customer and not the insurance company.
- The customer is made whole. They get paid quickly, and their deductible comes back when the money is recovered.
- It keeps insurance affordable. Money that comes back helps keep costs down for everyone.
Three questions every file answers
- Where did it start?The originThe dishwasher's water line
- Why did it happen?The causeThe connection was never tightened
- Who is responsible for the why?The responsible partyThe plumber who installed it
If the answer to the last question is another party, you have subrogation.
Every file, six simple steps
Each guide on Subrobuddy follows the same path, so you always know where you are. Tap a step to see real examples.
-
Identify
Find where it started, why it happened, and who is responsible.
Identify
Why it matters: You can't recover from someone you haven't found.
- A car drives through the living room wall. Who was driving?
- A water heater bursts a week after a plumber installed it.
- A fire starts in the neighbor's unit and spreads next door.
-
Notify
Let every party who may be responsible know, early.
Notify
Why it matters: Evidence disappears. Early notice gives everyone a fair chance to inspect it.
- Car into a house? Notify the driver, the vehicle's owner, and their insurance carrier.
- Check the car for recalls. If one applies, notify the manufacturer too.
- Recent repairs on the car, like brakes? Notify the mechanic who did the work.
-
Investigate
Gather the proof of what happened.
Investigate
Why it matters: A hunch isn't proof. Evidence shows who is responsible.
- Pull the police or fire marshal report.
- Keep the failed part, like the burst supply line.
- Set up a lab exam and invite every party to attend.
-
Demand
Once the claim is paid, ask for the money back.
Demand
Why it matters: Paying the claim is what gives you the right to ask for it back.
- Send a demand to the other side's insurance carrier.
- Ask for the insured's damages plus their deductible.
- Include the proof: photos, estimates, and the expert's findings.
-
Negotiate
Work toward a fair number with the other side.
Negotiate
Why it matters: The first answer is rarely yes. This gets you to a fair number without a lawsuit.
- They blame someone else? Point back to the evidence.
- Keep the facts on paper. Talk about fault on the phone.
- Low offer? Back up your number with invoices and estimates.
-
Settle
Review the release, collect, and close the file.
Settle
Why it matters: Everyone signs off, the money comes in, and the insured gets their deductible back.
- Read the release line by line before anyone signs.
- Make sure it names the right parties and the right loss.
- Collect the payment and get the deductible back to the insured.
Cause-of-loss guides
Pick the kind of loss on your desk today and get the full playbook.
Drafting tips that save you headaches
Small habits that keep your letters clean and your files moving.
Facts on paper, fault on the phone
Letters stick to what happened. Save the "who's to blame" talk for a call.
Say "responsible," not "negligent"
It keeps the tone calm and gets more people to respond.
Give 9 business days
That's a fair window for replies to a scene or lab exam invitation.
Notice letters don't mention payment
At notice, usually nothing has been paid yet, so leave it out.
Name and claim number up top
Put the insured's name and the claim number in every subject line, so it lands on the right desk.
Certified mail for the paper trail
For anything time-sensitive, send it certified. The signed receipt helps prove they got it and when.
Talking to a homeowner?
Send them to Subrobuddy. It walks everyday people through going after the one responsible themselves.
Your next file just got easier.
Grab a letter, follow the steps, and get the money back.