The question
A fellow specialist sent this one over, and it's a situation every one of us will see:
Do I even bother sending a demand or setting up a claim with the carrier on a new Michigan vehicle-hit-property claim? Or close? It came to me new with an expired statute. Loss is 11/2024.
A vehicle struck an insured's building (or fence, or garage) in Michigan. The file just landed on your desk nearly two years later. Michigan's clock on these is one year. So is it dead on arrival?
Short answer: don't close it on day one. Most of these will close, but a few won't, and it only takes a few calls to find out which kind you have.
Why Michigan plays by different rules
Michigan is a no-fault state, and it treats vehicle-into-property damage differently than almost everywhere else:
- The vehicle's insurance carrier pays, not the driver. Michigan requires Property Protection Insurance (PPI) on every auto policy. It pays for damage the vehicle does to buildings, fences, walls and other property, regardless of who was at fault, up to $1 million.
- You deal with the carrier directly. The PPI claim goes to the vehicle owner's insurance carrier (or the driver's, if the owner's can't be reached).
- The deadline is one year from the accident. A lawsuit for PPI benefits has to be filed within one year, and it doesn't get the extensions some other no-fault claims get.
- Your client doesn't get more time than the insured. Michigan courts have held that a carrier recovering what it paid is bound by the same one-year limit as its insured.
For a November 2024 loss, that window closed in November 2025.
The four checks before you close
1. Confirm coverage. Find out if the vehicle was insured on the date of loss, and with which insurance carrier. Everything else depends on this answer.
2. Ask if a claim was opened and responsibility accepted. If the vehicle's carrier already has an open claim, or already accepted responsibility, send the demand and your documentation to that claim. Carriers sometimes honor what they've already accepted. Just know that an open claim by itself doesn't stop the one-year clock.
3. No claim open? Ask them to open one. Send the letter and ask. If they decline because of the one-year limit, you've done your job. Close it with a clean note.
4. Uninsured vehicle? Now it's a whole different claim. Michigan's no-fault protection only covers vehicles that had the required insurance in effect. If the vehicle was uninsured, that protection is gone, and you can pursue the responsible driver and owner directly under Michigan's regular three-year property damage deadline. A November 2024 loss would stay open until November 2027. Collecting from an uninsured person is its own challenge, so check for assets before you invest heavy time.
Quick decision guide
| What you find | What to do |
|---|---|
| Insured vehicle, claim open, responsibility accepted | Send the demand to that claim |
| Insured vehicle, no claim on file | Ask the carrier to open one; close if they decline |
| Insured vehicle, carrier denies on the one-year limit | Close with a documented note |
| Uninsured vehicle | Pursue the responsible driver and owner directly; three-year deadline |
Can you still ask after the deadline?
Yes, you can ask. Sending a demand or asking a carrier to open a claim after the deadline isn't illegal. The deadline doesn't erase the claim. It gives the carrier a defense it can choose to use, and if it doesn't raise that defense, it loses it.
What's okay:
- Sending the demand and asking the carrier to review it
- Asking them to open a claim
- Accepting payment if the carrier chooses to pay anyway, which some do on clear, well-documented claims
Where the line is:
- Don't misrepresent anything. Never suggest the deadline hasn't passed or that they're required to pay. Just present the facts and ask.
- Filing a lawsuit is different. A suit filed on a claim everyone knows is time-barred can lead to sanctions against the filer. Michigan courts can penalize filings with no legal basis. That's a decision for counsel.
- Take "no" gracefully. Once they cite the one-year limit, close it and document the denial.
Keep your demand to the facts on paper. A factual demand that says "please review and advise" is a fair ask.
Who gets hurt most by the delay? The insured.
When a Michigan vehicle-into-property file reaches subrogation after the one-year window, the client carrier loses its recovery. But the insured often loses more, and they had no say in the delay.
What the insured can lose:
- Their deductible. In a timely claim, the deductible is part of the recovery and goes back to the insured. Once the deadline passes, that money is usually gone for good.
- Their uncovered losses. Anything their policy didn't pay (items over limits, excluded items, extra costs) could have been claimed from the vehicle's insurance carrier through PPI. That claim has the same one-year clock.
- A clean claim history. The loss was paid on the insured's own policy when the vehicle's carrier should have carried it. A paid claim with no recovery stays on their record and can follow them at renewal.
- Time to act on their own. Most insureds don't know Michigan gives them a PPI claim directly against the vehicle's carrier. If nobody tells them early, they miss their chance too.
Why this matters for every specialist:
It was their property. The insured paid premiums, paid a deductible, and trusted the process to get them whole. A file that sits too long before referral quietly moves the cost onto the one person who wasn't responsible for any of it.
What the insured's carrier should have done:
- Spotted it at first notice. A vehicle striking a building in Michigan is a PPI claim. The claim adjuster should flag it the day the loss is reported.
- Gathered the vehicle details right away. Driver and owner names, the vehicle's insurance carrier and policy number, and the police report number.
- Referred it to subrogation early. Weeks after the loss, not months. The one-year date should be noted on the file from day one.
- Put the vehicle's carrier on notice. A notice letter to the vehicle's insurance carrier, well inside the one-year window, including the insured's deductible.
- Told the insured about PPI. Let them know the vehicle's carrier may be responsible for their damages, including their deductible and anything their own policy doesn't cover.
- Kept the insured updated. So they aren't left wondering whether their money is coming back.
What you can do on the next one:
- Flag Michigan vehicle-into-property files the day they're assigned, and note the one-year date at the top of the file.
- Send the notice to the vehicle's insurance carrier early, with the deductible included in the amount.
- Let the insured know their out-of-pocket costs are being included, so nothing of theirs gets left behind.
Fast referral protects the client. It protects the insured even more.
Close it the right way
If it does close, your file note protects you and your client. Include:
- The date the file was assigned to you
- The date of loss and the date the one-year window closed
- Coverage confirmed (carrier name and claim number, if any)
- The carrier's response, and the date you received it
- Why the file is closing
A file that came to you already past the deadline isn't your miss. A clean note makes sure nobody can say it was.
The takeaway
An expired deadline on arrival usually means a closed file, but not always. Confirm coverage, check for an open claim, ask, and look hard for an uninsured vehicle. That last one is where a "dead" Michigan claim can come back to life.
Each investigation is different, but the formula is the same.
This post is general information to help specialists work their files. It isn’t legal advice. Rules change and differ by state, so check current law or with counsel on any file with real money at stake.