Step-by-step checklist
Identify
Hands off until the expert arrives. Nothing at the scene gets touched, moved, repaired, or thrown out until the origin and cause investigator has secured it. Evidence that's moved early can sink the whole recovery.
Notify
Investigate
Before you release the scene. Check every one of these first:
- The origin and cause investigator has finished documenting the scene (photos, diagrams, measurements) and shared their first findings.
- Any evidence they need is collected, tagged and in storage under chain of custody.
- Every possible responsible party got the joint scene exam notice, and either attended or the 9 business days passed.
- No one has asked in writing for more time or another inspection, or that request has been settled.
- The client approved the release, and it's noted in the file.
- Then tell the insured and the adjuster that repairs can start, and send each party a short note with the date the scene was released.
Demand, negotiate, and settle
The rest of this guide is for Subrobuddy members
The steps above are free. Try every tool free for 7 days to see the full guide: who's responsible, the proof to get, the defenses to expect, and the letters to send.
1. Identify
How these losses happen
- Foul balls or home runs landing in a parking lot or on nearby homes
- Golf balls from a course or driving range hitting homes and cars
- Break-ins, vandalism, or fights in a stadium lot with weak security
- Tailgating grills or fires damaging nearby cars
- Crowds or fans damaging nearby property after a game
Is there anyone to recover from?
| What you find | Who may be responsible |
|---|---|
| Your insured was a fan and parked in the lot, hit by a normal foul ball | Often no recovery. Many courts apply the baseball rule. |
| A nearby home is hit over and over | The venue or golf course, for not putting up netting after notice |
| A golfer's shot hit a home or car | The golfer. The course too if the layout aims shots at homes. |
| A break-in or vandalism in a paid lot | The venue or lot operator, if security was lacking |
| A tailgater's grill set a car on fire | The tailgater |
| A team or venue event damaged a neighbor's property | The team, venue, or event organizer |
The baseball rule: in many states a venue that screens the most dangerous seats owes spectators no more. This usually applies to fans in the stands. It is weaker for cars in the lot and much weaker for neighbors who never bought a ticket.
2. Notify and investigate
Evidence checklist
3. Demand, negotiate, and settle
Liability theories: negligence, nuisance and trespass for repeated strikes, premises liability for lot security, and negligent course or field design.
Defenses to expect
| Defense | How to answer it |
|---|---|
| The baseball rule applies | It usually covers fans in the stands, not neighbors or cars outside the venue |
| Assumption of risk: you parked here | Ask if signs warned of it. A paid lot owes reasonable care. |
| The parking ticket disclaims damage | Read it. Many do not excuse the operator's own negligence. |
| The homeowner bought next to a golf course | Repeated strikes after notice can still be a nuisance or trespass |
| We can't tell which player hit it | Go after the venue for the missing netting instead |
4. Letters for this loss
| Step | Letter |
|---|---|
| Identify | Subrogation Opening Letter to Insured |
| Notify | Notice of Subrogation Interest and Insurance Request, to Adverse Carrier |
| Investigate | Evidence Preservation and Joint Scene Exam Notice |
| Demand | Subrogation Demand to Adverse Carrier |
| Negotiate | Second Demand with Escalation Notice |
| Settle | Release Review Checklist, Deductible Reimbursement |
Related guides: Vehicle into Structure, and Fireworks Losses.