Step-by-step checklist
Identify
Hands off until the expert arrives. Nothing at the scene gets touched, moved, repaired, or thrown out until the origin and cause investigator has secured it. Evidence that's moved early can sink the whole recovery.
Notify
Investigate
Before you release the scene. Check every one of these first:
- The origin and cause investigator has finished documenting the scene (photos, diagrams, measurements) and shared their first findings.
- Any evidence they need is collected, tagged and in storage under chain of custody.
- Every possible responsible party got the joint scene exam notice, and either attended or the 9 business days passed.
- No one has asked in writing for more time or another inspection, or that request has been settled.
- The client approved the release, and it's noted in the file.
- Then tell the insured and the adjuster that repairs can start, and send each party a short note with the date the scene was released.
Demand
Negotiate
Settle
The rest of this guide is for Subrobuddy members
The steps above are free. Try every tool free for 7 days to see the full guide: who's responsible, the proof to get, the defenses to expect, and the letters to send.
1. Identify
Common causes
| Cause | What goes wrong |
|---|---|
| Blocked city sewer main | Grease, roots, or debris block the main, and sewage backs up into the lowest drains on the street |
| Poor maintenance | The city skipped cleaning or ignored earlier complaints about the same main |
| Overloaded system | Heavy rain overwhelms a combined sewer or a system that was too small |
| Water main break | An old or corroded main breaks and floods nearby homes and basements |
| Pump station failure | A lift station loses power or a pump fails, and sewage backs up |
| Contractor damage | A crew working on the street crushes or blocks the main or the lateral |
Responsible parties to consider
- The city, county, or sewer or water district that owns the main
- A private utility company that runs the system for the city
- A contractor working on the main, the street, or nearby lines
- A neighbor or business that dumped grease or debris into the system
The lateral vs. the main
The insured usually owns the lateral, the pipe from the house to the main. A backup caused by roots or a break in the insured's own lateral usually has no recovery. A blockage in the public main points at the city. A camera inspection answers this question, so get it early.
2. Notify and investigate
Notice deadlines come first
Claims against a government body usually require a written notice of claim before anything else. The deadline varies by state and even by city, and can be as short as 30 to 180 days. Some states set special rules just for sewer backups. Find the rule for that city on day one, and calendar it.
Adding the city or water utility to your letter. Use the Party Finder to add the city, sewer district or water company, and save their claims address so it fills in for the next file. Many cities require their own notice-of-claim form, so check the city's website before you mail.
Who to put on notice
- The city clerk, risk management office, or the office the law names
- The sewer or water department that runs the system
- Any contractor who worked on the line
Evidence checklist
3. Demand, negotiate, and settle
Liability theories
- Negligent maintenance or operation of the sewer or water system
- Failure to fix a known problem after earlier complaints
- Nuisance or trespass, in some states
- A state statute that allows sewer backup claims
Defenses to expect
| Defense | How to answer it |
|---|---|
| Governmental immunity | Many states waive immunity for sewer backups or for maintenance failures. Design and budget decisions are usually protected, but routine upkeep often is not. |
| Late notice | Prevention is the only cure. Send notice early, to every office that might need it. |
| It was the insured's lateral | The camera inspection. Show the blockage was in the main. |
| Unusual rainfall, an act of nature | Rainfall records, and whether the same main backed up in normal storms before |
| No prior notice of a problem | Past complaints and work orders for the same main |
Negotiating and settling
- Many cities use a third-party claims administrator. Get the claim number and the adjuster's name.
- Some states cap damages against government bodies. Check the cap before you set expectations with the client.
- Review the release with the release checklist.
- Close with the standard closing letter and the deductible reimbursement letter.
4. Letters for this loss
| Step | Letter | Sent to |
|---|---|---|
| Identify | Subrogation Opening Letter to Insured | Insured: plumber's report, photos, city work order number |
| Notify | Notice of Subrogation Interest and Insurance Request | City, district, or contractor (adapt it to meet the notice-of-claim rules) |
| Investigate | Evidence Preservation and Joint Scene Exam Notice | City, utility, and contractors |
| Demand | Subrogation Demand to Responsible Party or to Adverse Carrier | City or its claims administrator |
| Negotiate | Second Demand with Escalation Notice, Tolling Agreement Request | City or administrator |
| Settle | Release Review Checklist, Closing (Made Whole) or Pro Rata, Deductible Reimbursement | Client and insured |
| No recovery | No Recovery Closing Letter | Client, for example when the blockage was in the insured's lateral |
Sources