← 🏘️ Contractors, tenants, and neighbors guides

Tenant and Landlord Losses

Tenant and landlord claims run both ways. A tenant can damage the landlord's building, and a landlord can damage a tenant's belongings. Before you pursue a tenant, you must check two things: the lease, and whether the state treats the tenant as a co-insured under the landlord's policy.

What it coversBoth directions of claims, the Sutton rule, lease waivers

Step-by-step checklist

Identify

Contact the claim adjuster right away. Ask them to hold the scene and for permission to retain an expert at the client's expense. Note the call in the file.
On every claim, ask the client whether they want an origin and cause investigator to review the scene, or confirm one is already assigned. Note their answer in the file so the decision is on record.
Make sure no evidence is touched or moved until the expert has secured the scene
Get the client's approval for the scene exam cost. Most run at least $1,600 with travel, the day rate, and expenses.
Figure out the direction: tenant damaged the building, or landlord damaged the tenant's things?
Get the signed lease and any addendums
Check the state's rule on tenants as implied co-insureds
Check the lease for a waiver of subrogation

Hands off until the expert arrives. Nothing at the scene gets touched, moved, repaired, or thrown out until the origin and cause investigator has secured it. Evidence that's moved early can sink the whole recovery.

Notify

Send notice and an insurance request to the tenant or landlord
Ask the landlord for the tenant's proof of renter's insurance
Notify their carrier

Investigate

Pull maintenance requests, texts, and emails
Get the move-in inspection and the cause report
Use the guide for the cause of loss (fire, water, and so on) for the rest of the investigation

Demand

Review payments and out-of-pocket costs
Sort the supports into photos, estimates, invoices, and reports
Send the full demand packet

Negotiate

Ask the renter's liability limits early
Uninsured tenant? Consider a payment plan.
If liability is accepted, negotiate. If not, review for ADR.

Settle

Review the release
Receive payment, issue the deductible and client payments
Final file review, then close

1. Identify

Claims run both ways

Your client insures	Loss caused by	Examples	Pursue
The landlord's building	The tenant	Cooking fire, overflowing tub, candle, smoking, a tenant-installed appliance	The tenant and their renter's liability policy
The tenant's belongings	The landlord	Ignoring a reported leak, faulty wiring, a failed building system the landlord maintains	The landlord and their liability policy
One tenant's belongings	Another tenant	A fire or leak in the unit next door or above	The other tenant and their renter's policy

The Sutton rule: is the tenant an implied co-insured?

In Sutton v. Jondahl (Oklahoma, 1975), the court held that a tenant was an implied co-insured under the landlord's fire policy, because the tenant's rent effectively helps pay for that insurance. An insurer can't subrogate against its own insured, so under this rule the landlord's insurer can't pursue the tenant for a negligent fire.

States fall into three groups:

Pro-subrogation: the landlord's insurer can pursue a negligent tenant.
Anti-subrogation (Sutton rule): the tenant is treated as an implied co-insured, and subrogation is barred.
Case-by-case: the court looks at the lease to see what the landlord and tenant expected.

Check the state's rule before you spend money on a tenant claim. State-by-state charts are listed in the sources below. In case-by-case states, the lease language decides the claim.

2. Notify and investigate

Read the lease first. Look for:

A waiver of subrogation. Common in commercial leases, and sometimes in residential ones. It can end the claim.
Insurance requirements. A lease that requires the tenant to carry renter's liability insurance helps show the parties expected the tenant to be responsible for damage they cause. That matters in case-by-case states.
Who maintains what. Appliances, plumbing, HVAC, and smoke detectors. This decides who was responsible for the failed item.
Indemnity clauses, where the tenant agrees to pay for damage they cause

Who to put on notice

The tenant, or the landlord and property manager
Their liability carrier. Leases often require proof of renter's insurance, so the landlord may have the policy information on file.

Evidence checklist

The signed lease and any addendums
Maintenance requests and repair records. A tenant's written complaint about a leak is proof the landlord knew about it.
Move-in inspection reports and photos
The fire department report or plumber's report on the cause
Scene photos, and the failed item (see the guide for that cause of loss)
Proof of the tenant's renter's insurance

3. Demand, negotiate, and settle

Liability theories

Against a tenant: negligence, and breach of the lease's duty to return the property in good condition or to indemnify
Against a landlord: negligence in maintaining the property, and failure to repair after notice

Defenses to expect

Defense	How to answer it
The tenant is an implied co-insured	The state's rule, and in case-by-case states, lease language showing the tenant was expected to insure their own liability.
The lease waives subrogation	Read the exact wording. Some waivers only cover certain types of loss or only apply to the extent of insurance.
The landlord didn't know about the problem	The tenant's maintenance requests, texts, and emails.
The tenant can't pay	Their renter's policy. Without one, consider a payment plan or collections.

Negotiating and settling

Renter's liability limits are often low. Ask early, and use the limited coverage notice if the loss will exceed them.
Uninsured tenants are common. Direct demands and payment plans are often the realistic path.
Review the release with the release checklist, then close with the standard closing letter and the deductible reimbursement letter.

4. Letters for this loss

Step	Letter	Sent to
Identify	Subrogation Opening Letter to Insured	Insured: lease, maintenance requests
Notify	Notice of Subrogation Interest and Insurance Request	Tenant or landlord
Notify	Notice of Subrogation Interest to Adverse Carrier	Their carrier
Investigate	Evidence Preservation and Joint Scene Exam Notice and to Responsible Party	All parties
Demand	Subrogation Demand to Adverse Carrier or to Responsible Party	Carrier, or an uninsured tenant
Negotiate	Limited Coverage Notice, Second Demand	Tenant or landlord
Settle	Release Review Checklist, Closing (Made Whole) or Pro Rata, Deductible Reimbursement	Client and insured
No recovery	No Recovery Closing Letter	Client, for example when the Sutton rule or a lease waiver applies

Sources